Log in

No account? Create an account
29 October 2009 @ 08:19 pm
sunnytyler001 asked me...  
Leave me a comment saying "Resistance is Futile."
• I'll respond by asking you five questions so I can satisfy my curiosity
• Update your journal with the answers to the questions
• Include this explanation in the post and offer to ask other people questions

1. You are Rose and the Doctor (for once) gives you the choice: a life of adventures with him or a life of love with Ten 2. What do you choose?
This is a tough one, and in the D/R fandom nothing starts a wankwar faster than asking who Rose should have chosen. Why didn't you just ask me about abortion, or gay marriage? lol.

Seriously though, I think that scene on the beach is one of the most romantic things I've ever seen. Everyone thinks the Doctor didn't give Rose a choice, but I think he did. In his usual fashion he manipulated the situation so that she would chose TenII, but she still ultimately made the decision. I love TenI. I love him so much I cry with him when he cries and I want him to have Rose forever, but he can't. This is the next best thing and he knew it. This partially human doctor can give Rose what TenI can't. A life together. I would chose that over adventure and so would TenI if he could. He's said as much.
If you'd like to read my reasoning on this opinion and what I use to back it up, you can find it here

2. Do you think Rose will ever get any 'consequences' for the Bad wolf?
I used to really hope so. I'm a huge fan of fanfics where Rose gets to live as long as the original Doctor due to her time as the Bad Wolf. I've even written one myself. The idea of them being together for centuries is very appealing. However, now that she's with the duplicate Doctor, I really, really hope she's still very human. I find the idea of her watching him grow old without her even more painful than the reverse.

3. What is your favorite David Tennant character? Peter Carlisle, the Doctor, ...?
I've seen David in many different Roles. One of my absolute favorite things about him is that he is so talented that he can become any character he wants to. This is especially apparent in the Doctor Who episode "Human Nature," where he plays two very different men at almost the same time. It is really obvious which character he is at any given time and the performance is just brilliant.

That being said, despite the sexiness of Casanova and Peter Carlisle, the comedic brilliance of Mr. Gibson and Chris the driving instructor, and the impressive Hamlet, I will always love our beloved Tenth Doctor the best. To put it simply, he had me at "Oh hold on, that's the Lion King."

4. Soooo... Ten 1 stops Ten 2 & Rose's wedding (The way he stopped Sarah Jane's). What happens?
I can't imagine a more painful situation than this. For the Doctor to stop a wedding he pretty much planned there would have to be something really, really wrong going on. Perhaps Rose has been replaced with an evil clone? Or the wedding rings have been replaced with tracking devices by invading aliens. Either way it makes for some pretty mixed up emotions on Rose's part, some serious resentment on the part of TenII, and some pretty fast talking from TenI.

5. What is your first name?
My name is Sarah. Actually, my maiden name was Sarah Smith. But alas, my middle name is not Jane.
Current Mood: contemplativecontemplative
Sarah: Doctor Who - Four/Sarahpie_is_good on October 30th, 2009 02:31 am (UTC)
My middle name is Jane! We should have combined forces and created the best name. ;)

Resistance is futile!
svanderslice: DW - 10 Come With Me (animated)svanderslice on October 30th, 2009 02:38 am (UTC)
But then we'd have the same name, and then the awesomeness might fade a bit. Don't you agree?

Anyway, here are your questions.

1. What is your favorite fandom of all time and why is it your favorite?
2. If you had the chance to have a real conversation with David Tennant what would you say first (besides hello my name is Sarah)?"
3. What is your favorite book, how many times have you read it, and why is it your favorite? (yes, this does count as one question because I say so)
4. What do you want to be when you grow up? (I'm still wondering myself and I'm 27).
5. What is your favorite personality trait that you have?
sunnytyler001sunnytyler001 on October 30th, 2009 04:53 pm (UTC)
Resistance is FUTILE! :D
svanderslice: DW - Dalek Procrastinate!svanderslice on October 30th, 2009 05:57 pm (UTC)
1. What is your favorite D/R fanfiction of all time and why? (please post a link if possible)
2. List five ways that Doctor Who has significantly changed your life.
3.If you had 10 million tax free dollars, what would you honestly and truly do with it?
4. If you owned Doctor Who, how would you have written Billie Piper out of the show? (she wants to leave you have no choice)
5. Okay, you still own Doctor Who, how would you have written Catherine Tate out?